The unfolding Hyflux saga is like a cheesy Taiwanese drama series – so bad that its good. Why is that so, if you may ask? After all, 34,000 investors had lost their life savings investing in Hyflux preference shares and perpetual securities. In my opinion, there are plenty of important lessons to be learned out of this fiasco. And Hyflux investors had better learn from this episode or it would be like throwing good money after bad.
From the implosion of Lehman Brothers’ Minibonds in 2009 to the toxic gold buy-back schemes to the outrageous Swiber junk bond defaults, Singapore had witnessed numerous investment tragedies. Some of the investment schemes were so downright ridiculous that you would be surprised many Singaporeans actually bought into them. For sure, Hyflux saga is not the first, but it will not be the last as well. What made this Hyflux saga so intriguing is that investors had not learned the lessons through the years. Many of the Hyflux investors were also previously investors of Minibonds, gold buy-back schemes or Swiber corporate bonds.
To make matters worse, trading of Hyflux shares were halted since last year, giving shareholders no way of running for their lives. No wonder investors are angry with founder Olivia Lum. She simply gives them no way out. If Hyflux shares were not suspended, at least share investors can short-sell shares and claw back some losses through short-term trading.
Hyflux saga stems from crisis of confidence
Indeed, the whole Hyflux saga is nothing short of shambolic. You have Public Utilities Board (PUB) announcing its rights to take its key asset – Tuaspring desalination plant – at zero dollar if Hyflux’s default issues are not resolved by 30 April 2019. You have white knight SM Investments getting cold feet and considering to pull out at the last minute due to its claim of Hyflux holding back “material information”. There are so many twists and turns for Hyflux saga that no scriptwriter is capable of coming up with similar plot.
And then there is the voting of the restructuring scheme on 5 April 2019. Under the restructuring scheme, Hyflux retail preference shareholders and perpetual securities holders face recovery rate of only about 10%, out of which only 3% would be in cash. Against this backdrop, many investors are threatening to vote against the scheme. However, in doing so, they need to be mindful that they stand to get nothing if Hyflux went into liquidation, which is likely to happen if SM Investments decided to drop the rescue deal.
In my view, Hyflux’s troubles should stem from crisis of confidence among its bank creditors. By itself, the business model of water treatment is sustainable in a country like Singapore. But problems started to snowball when Hyflux decided to take on the Tuaspring Deslination project from PUB in 2011. The plant not only generates desalinated water, but also electricity. The entry into the energy market changed the business dynamic for Hyflux as it lacks competency in this segment. That deal also saw Hyflux taking on a massive $720million loan from Maybank.
Then the collapse of oil price in 2014 caused mayhem for Hyflux as it incurred losses from operating Tuaspring. The weak power market also led to delay in the sale of Tuaspring, Hyflux’s largest asset on hand. It was a perfect storm for Hyflux because if Olivia Lum had chosen to cut losses and sold off the plant, the bank creditors’ confidence would not be shaken and the house of cards would not have collapsed. But of course, all these are water under the bridge.
Taking ownership on investment losses
So what are the lessons for Hyflux investors? First of all, the argument that Hyflux investors do not deserve to suffer losses because many of them are retirees is [This is a premium article. The rest of the content is blocked and can be accessible by SG Wealth Builder Members only. To read the full content, please sign up as member.]
In a bid to raise financial literacy and reward SG Wealth Builder members, I am pleased to launch the Best SGX stock research campaign. Winner of this contest gets to receive cash prize of $1000!
The rationale for launching this activity is to level the playing field for retail investors, who often lack access to quality SGX stock research, especially homegrown SME stocks. Through this SGX stock research campaign, I hope to raise interest in SGX stocks among local investors, and at the same time, encourage members to share ideas and showcase their analytic skills. The winning entry will be published in this blog for learning purposes.
The winning SGX stock research article must cover a stock that is listed in Singapore Exchange (SGX) and should be engaging and interesting to read. From a story-telling perspective, you can share your best or worst SGX stock investments and what valuable lessons that can be gleaned. Ideally, the article should also contain data to back up the thesis and provides insightful analysis.
Winning prize: $1000
- This campaign is open to existing SG Wealth Builder Members only. If you are not a member, please sign up here. Email subscribers are not eligible.
- Each SG Wealth Builder member is entitled to submit one article only.
- Each article must be at least 1000 words in Microsoft Word document. Must not be published at any platform before. Any article found plagiarism would be automatically disqualified. You do not need to provide infographic or images but if you do, they must carry the applicable licenses.
- Email your submission to firstname.lastname@example.org from 1 April 2019 to 31 May 2019. Late submission will not be entertained.
- In your document submission, you must provide your member userid or email address.
- The winning entry will be announced on 7 June 2019 and the winner will be notified through email. He/she must give the consent for the article to be published in this blog in order to receive the cash prize.
- In the event of a lack of quality submissions, there may be no winner. However, under such circumstances, consolation prizes may be given for entries that do not meet the evaluation criteria.
Not a member yet? You may sign up to become a member of SG Wealth Builder. The full benefits and privileges of SG Wealth Builder Membership:
- Access to the latest premium articles of SG Wealth Builder
- Email notifications of latest blog articles
- Participate in SG Wealth Builder campaigns
- Request for coverage on stocks, insurance and other personal financial topics
- Comment in articles and Wealth Forum
SG Wealth Builder Membership
You may sign up for the SG Wealth Builder Membership for only $15 per month. As a member, you can access all the articles, including the premium ones.
Note: After payment is made, you will be prompted with registration form to create your user-id and personal password.